Which Country After Ireland will Legalize Gay Marriage?

Lesbians in Italy

Lesbians in Italy

Ireland’s landslide victory in what was once a predominantly Roman Catholic country, seems to have sped up the process in Australia and Italy.

Will Italy be the Next Country?

Rome Pride

Rome Pride

In Italy, the only country in Western Europe that does not provide any legal recognition to same-sex couples, Prime Minister Matteo Renzi vowed Sunday to bring civil union legislation to a vote by the end of the summer. Renzi previously promised to hold a vote on the proposal last year, but the legislation has failed to advance despite polls showing the Italian public overwhelmingly supportive of extending partnership rights.

“In my party on this issue — confidentially, in private — there are those who want more” than just civil unions, La Repubblica quoted Renzi as saying on Sunday. “But civil unions can no longer be postponed.”

Ireland’s Politicians Defied the Catholic Church

Irish Prime Minister, Enda Kenny, came out in support of same-sex marriage inspire of the Church putting heavy pressure on its believers.

.On Monday, the Vatican’s official newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano, published an article on the vote calling it a “challenge to the entire church.”

“The margin between the ‘yes’ (1,201,607) — equivalent to 62.1 percent — and the ‘no’ (734,300) was too large not to be accepted as a defeat,” the article said.

Church’s Power is Waning

Politicians in Catholic countries may have been unwilling to challenge the Church and its believers.  What Ireland has shown is that there are TWO churches – the institution of the Vatican – and the Church of the People.  Irish Catholic voters defied the Church and voted for justice and love.

It also quoted remarks first published in Corriere Della Sera by the secretary general of the Italian bishops’ conference, Monsignor Nunzio Galatino, that may hint at an acquiescence at least to civil unions. While the Church does not accept the “equivalence” between homosexual unions and the “traditional family,” Galatino said, he expressed a desire to “arrive at a solution that is in line with the common good while respecting the rights of everyone.”

The Rights of Everyone

Most LGBT people know that if we get rights – they will come from the law of the land – and not the churches.

Prie in Berlin, Germany

Prie in Berlin, Germany

In Germany, which has had civil unions for same-sex couples since 2001 but is the only other Western European country besides Italy where same-sex couples cannot marry, LGBT rights supporters are trying to use the Irish vote to pressure Chancellor Angela Merkel and her Christian Democratic Union Party. Merkel  remains opposed to marriage rights as well as allowing same-sex couples to jointly adopt children though  polls have shown three-quarters of Germans support marriage equality.

“I am confident that the Irish vote will accelerate equality in Germany,” Die Welt reported Green Party parliamentary leader Katrin Göring-Eckardt as saying. “It’s time, Ms. Merkel.”


Sydney Mardi Gras

Sydney Mardi Gras

Opposition leaders in both houses of the Australian Parliament are also saying they will attempt to bring forward legislation despite opposition from Prime Minister Tony Abbott, who campaigned against marriage equality during the 2013 election.

Australian polls  indicate that a majority of Australians support marriage equality, but Abbott ruled out the idea of holding a marriage referendum in the country in remarks after the Irish vote. So opposition leader Bill Shorten announced he would introduce marriage equality legislation in the House of Representatives on June 1, while Greens Party lawmaker Sarah Hanson-Young said she would introduce legislation in the Senate in June with plans to hold a vote on November 21.

In order to pass, this legislation would need some support of members of Abbott’s party, but he has so far resisted allowing a conscience vote that would allow lawmakers to break with the party line against marriage equality. Yesterday, Abbott’s sister Christine Forster — who is an out lesbian — reportedly called to allow a conscience vote.

Lawmakers are hoping moving the debate may force him to reconsider.

Come on, Australia, do the right thing – equality for all.   paula.


 Leave a Reply